Here's what I don't get- Wardens just got completely rebalanced in Chapter 4, and pretty much everyone was thrilled silly about it. No one was complaining; wardens and non-wardens rejoiced because such a fail class finally (FINALLY!) got the love it needed.
So, if everyone was happy, WHY ON EARTH would they go and more or less reinvent wardens AGAIN?
This is the main objection my guild's main warden has. He spent two years learning his class (he was wd/m all through Chapter 3, and went wd/w gleefully in Chap 4) and all of a sudden he finds all his go-to skills redefined. Poor kiddo hasn't logged on since patch day, and I don't blame him.
Even assuming they fix wd/w's tanking ability on Tuesday next, it doesn't justify Runewaker fooling around with the class for no apparent reason. Jeebus, who was it who had the signature that said, "Runewaker's Motto: It's not broken, let's fix that!" That's what they've done, and as someone upthread pointed out, not just to wardens. D/S and R/D both got broken skills rebroken in new and interesting ways. My poor d/s is going d/wd now- how messed up is that really? I mean, hey, I get an mdam buff out of it, so I'm not complaining too hard, but seriously, why would you "fix" a skill just to break it worse?
Now, we can argue and fuss and fight amongst ourselves when it comes to which skills and classes are OP and need a nerf- but literally NO ONE was complaining about wardens. Cause they WEREN'T BROKEN, in any way (well, except for maybe Chiron in PvP, and they didn't address that at all, and Chiron is an inconvenience, he doesn't deserve the nerf bat either).
When will they learn to do minor tweaks to individual skills instead of tossing whole classes into the industrial blender?
And @whoever was saying that wd/w's should just play whatever their other class is for a week- um, well, the vast majority of wd/w's have spent lots of time and dias modding plate gear for tanking. Why not tell a knight "Gee Bob, why don't you just try and dps for a week with your 40k pattack and 200k hp? You'll be fine! No, really!" It's not really doable for wd/w to just up and turn themselves into a dps class since they have gear that's just as specialized as any knight's.
The saddest thing is, wd/w already had to struggle to tank. While their great pdef and excellent single-target aggro made them good in boss fights, they relied on Frantic Briar to grab pats, and three seconds was a heck of a long time for them to have to wait to scoop up a whole patrol, and it made tanking trash hard for them. Making it an instant cast is fine, but 12 seconds is an insanely long time to expect a tank to be able to hold aggro on a group without losing some mobs. Replacing that AoE with one that only hits three mobs, in an era when patrols can have 8 mobs- isn't going to cut it.
Wardens already struggled tanking trash before- now it's impossible (unless they know something I don't, I won't claim to be a warden expert) and giving them back their lost pdef isn't going to solve that problem.
This is somewhat off-topic, but it seems like Runewaker is afraid of allowing any one class to excel at tanking both single targets and multiple mob patrols, and I think that's idiotic. Look at poor Knights- they have significantly less aggro gen than w/k's, Champions or Wardens (especially after this "buff")- but they excel at large trash pulls. Warrior/knights, champions and wardens can all hold a boss better than knights, but they all also struggle with trash. I'm not saying that these classes can't tank- obviously they all do. But there's really no good reason to single knights out for bad aggro gen, or deny good CC to the other tanking classes. Each and every tank class in RoM should be able to do both.
So, to Runewaker- WTF guys? We need our wardens to still be wardens, and we need our wd/w's able to actually tank, and tanking is more than just holding aggro on a boss and living through his attacks. If you have a yearning to fix things, please try and fix the things that are ACTUALLY BROKEN first. Please see the Knight class for a good example. Or maybe wander down the Varanas bridge and talk to Lieve. -_-