I do find it interesting that the food which is of no real use to anyone besides tanks is looked at as a highly desirable item that everyone drools over. So, what do non-tanks do with it? Looking at AH, I can see clear answer to the reason why people like those. What we got instead is a selection of buffs useful for most classes. Obviously, a huge disappointment to get something useful.
Some of us non-tanks actually
use egg rice during runs, siege, arena, etc. So yes, some of us who do
use them are a bit disappointed that they werent given away, as per usual in halloween events. Part of my enjoyment is not being 1 shot fodder in siege (the real reason i play, its fun, yeah its broken, but its fun), hence why I use egg rice.
Not only siege, but it has its uses in PvE as well. There have been many times that a tank has died (for whatever reason, the usual would be boulders off 4th tosh) and a P/K tanks the boss from 60-0, or 40-0, or what have you. And yes, even I have tanked ToSH bosses with a last second egg rice use +wand/shield equip and changing to pdef food. Egg rice isn't all about greed. Some of us DO use it for our own self enjoyment, whatever it may be.
I dont see a problem in handing them out tbh. People sell them, so what? It gives a nice boost to those who arent as fortunate to make easy gold like some of us do. And those of us (well, not me. I'm always poor, but i buy when I can) who have the gold, can spend it. Egg Rice is a relief for both sides. Availability for one, and a source of income for the other.
And yes, I would take egg rice over common, craftable items anyday. Not saying I don't thank the CMs for the free handouts, its nice, and thank you. But I'm fairly certain its common knowledge that a larger group want Egg Rice.