You are not logged in.

Applications: [GameMaster: OPEN] | [Volunteer Testers: OPEN]


This forum will be permanently shut down on Friday 13.07.2018
Please copy or save all important information from old forum before they will be deactivated
We have moved to new board. https://forum.runesofmagic.gameforge.com/Come join us.

Heddin

Trainee

  • "Heddin" started this thread

Posts: 126

Location: govinda

  • Send private message

1

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 5:43pm

afk with ingame skill that does auto-response = ban

Dear Rom community,

I would like to make this post for two reasons, first to ensure community is aware so that you don’t make mistake I did, and second small hope that your feedback on the situation may convince GF and customer support to reconsider how they view the situation. I don’t want it to become a flame thread and I hope given the general importance for community to know this will allow thread to stand and not be closed.

I will give my personal example but when you read it you can see how it may potentially be applied to other cases. My account was permanently banned after I was afk several times on my r/m in vicinity of monsters while having Enchanted Throw (enchants your projectile weapons so that every normal attack will carry additional Throw damage) elite on (once activated it stays forever). Another elite in conjunction with enchanted throw gives you Vengeance Sting (If you are attacked while Enchanted Throw is in effect, this will inflict 50.0% main hand weapon DPS + 1.00 x Projectile Damage physical damage to your attacker.) Hence, you can be afk and if monster attacks you, they will get hit by reflected damage and may eventually die, hence you gain tp/exp. Please note that you DO take hits meaning you lose life points, dura etc, there is no auto heal. Hence you can’t afk for too long or you will die.

The way GF views the above is you perform automated action while afk and they equate it to botting. I am guilty of using in game skill (as designed by RW in my opinion) to let monsters hit me and with reflected damage eventually die, I did not use any external programs, auto anything, no macros, did not loot anything. Below please find rule 7.3 which they use for this, so you can judge by yourself. I can understand the permanent ban if I would have used external means in conjunction to that skill, but I did not. I am continuing to work with customer support but no luck so far. I am very sad about this situation; I consider myself an honest player, I played the game for many years and never used botting programs. If anyone can have a suggestion how I can proceed beyond customer support, please email me via forum email option.

To summarize, please be aware that even if you use in game skills, but you are afk and that skill lets you do something automated (like reflected damage), you can be permanently banned. I wish someone posted the above so I could avoid my situation, as I would have never set it up if I knew it was considered botting by GF.

Would it be perhaps possible to differentiate the use of ingame skills that trigger auto-response from external auto-programs? I personally don’t think this is botting to use ingame skill, but its irrelevant as what is only relevant is how GF views/applies its rules. I just hope there could be some common sense/common ground.

Rule 7.3 (full T&Cs: http://agbserver.frogster-online.com/enG…of-Magic.html):
The user is also prohibited from running the online game (including all individual web pages) with programmes other than the Internet browser or the client programme that has been provided. This refers in particular to so-called bots and other tools designed to replace or supplement the Web interface. Scripts and completely or partially automated programmes that provide the user with an advantage over other users are also prohibited. These include auto-refresh-functions and other integrated mechanisms of the Internet browser, if they involve automated operations.

Kind regards,
Heddin, Govinda, USA
Proud member of Bteam

2

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 6:40pm

Agree that permanent ban is too severe, I would've made it temporary.

Still, anyone who goes AFK in the middle of spawning mobs would be dead, except if you class has the auto-retaliate capability, like R/M or WD. So, the question is - did the person do a mistake or is he AFK farming XP/TP/Relationship points?

Was the location close to safe spot? I had a few cases where I misjudged mobs aggro range, and ended up dead as R/S... as R/M, I would've lived easily. Even parked in most mob spawning spots, any decently statted R/M can kill the mobs fast enough and with little enough damage to self to get back to full HP between spawns. That lets R/M do this almost indefinitely.

And, it was mentioned during Pit meeting that using auto-retaliate skills in mob spawning spots while AFK is perma-ban. I am not sure there is much recourse, sorry to say, but I do hope they change it to temp ban. It is not such a huge offense to deserve perma-ban.

Edit: I hope mods dont remove the thread for discussing bans - it is a good reminder for people not to do it.
-- Rustyx --- 92R / 92S / 92M on Reni (Guild KnightShift). Yes, running the new FOTM R/M, cause I am not elf enough to be WD/S.

Oh, and people who have more than 3 classes are clinically insane.


Lemonater

Professional

Posts: 615

Location: In a house

Occupation: Christian

  • Send private message

3

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 7:02pm

AFK clarification, plz

This might be a good timer ta asker a few questions: Is AFK unarmed, defense, weapon skill buildin a bannable offense? Usin PAC in yer house (we know not ter user it by the vendor)?

4

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 7:14pm

So this tells me not to go afk if mobs can attack you.
And in mu ipinion if it can be done by only a couple class combos it should not be allowed.
So if you are a r/m maybe make sure that your buff isnt on when you afk.
Zymologist wl/ch/m/p
Matronmalice p/s/m
Ceviche wl/ch

karmakarma

Master Procrastinator

Posts: 442

Location: Miami

Occupation: Diesel Mechanic (semi-trucks/tractor-trailers)

  • Send private message

5

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 7:22pm

In before close
LifeFire - Eternal - Grimdal
Mage/Priest/Knight
82/82/82

Give a macro, Take a Macro
Lifefire's Collections

Heddin

Trainee

  • "Heddin" started this thread

Posts: 126

Location: govinda

  • Send private message

6

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 7:23pm

Quote from vfwiffo "And, it was mentioned during Pit meeting that using auto-retaliate skills in mob spawning spots while AFK is perma-ban. "

This is something that must be clearly listed in T&C. It is not, at least was not two days ago when I checked. It is also not listed in recent supplemented rules posted by CM Mika. I urge those who can to post an update to rules that will explicitly state what it appears Pit decided to treat as permanent ban. I dont understand, however, how the decision like that can be applied without official post regarding that matter.
Proud member of Bteam

Inferiority

Professional

Posts: 1,062

Location: Scotland

Occupation: Educator

  • Send private message

7

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 7:37pm

Agree that permanent ban is too severe, I would've made it temporary.

I recall reading somewhere that the policy on bans is that first time offenders get a temporary ban but repeat offenders are given the permanent version. Unfortunately, this puts Heddin in a very shady light... :(
Inferiority Complex - Original wearer of the Snow Combat Drum!
Mage/Priest on Erebos // Warrior/Rogue (and millions of alts) on Aurora & Agenor
http://romhiddenquests.ml/ // RoM Client & Patches Manual Download
Everyone's name is better than mine! :(

gigilomann

XxXGigilomannXxX

Posts: 2,213

Location: The one and only, Ohio.

Occupation: I Do Work

Mood: Love

  • Send private message

8

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 7:37pm

As i recall, another thread, last chapter, was a similar thread, getting banned. Same reason. A r/m using enchanted throw to bot.

Now, they might've deleted the thread, however it was the same situation, but obviously, you should know that botting is against the rules, afk, outside program or not.

I would jsut like to also poitn out that I myself am aware ofpeople botting on my server, and they still havent been banned. So not sure why you have been.
For you to live or die is in my hands, In Gigi we trust.

-"Retired as one of the best, Will always be remembered for KT, RT->RT Dia, and GCH"- -Palenque- -XxXGigilomannXxX- -P/K/S-


9

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 7:51pm

Well they could as well ban all scouts during CHIII, because they were using broken DEX ADF multiplier... Come on... Making skill last 15mins OK, but banning for using ingame skill, what's next banning for crafting on afk, clearing debt by library??? Not to mention afk addon on auto accept inv...

10

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 7:57pm

Hmmm...
Not sure why Heddin had deserved a perma ban when there was a youtube video(s) where a raid of people were AFK botting family relationship buffs....
It is not fair to ban one person for something that was over looked before.

Video links removed, please do not repost them -- Kalvan


Does this also mean that if my pet is petcrafting and I walk away from the computer to get a drink... I am now Botting? and I might get banned?

Also if you have a toon or alt sitting on the crystal tower in siege... that is botting too ?

Just need to be sure so I dont get banned from something I have invested some $$ in :)
Thanks
Calon
The grass is greener when you are in Paradise.

11

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 7:59pm

I think we're coming far afield from the OP's statement: he got banned for killing mobs while afk, gaining xp/tp when he wasn't at the keyboard.

Most ppl I know that go afk, do so by popping recall, popping HSH, running to a spot they know no mobs appear. & most of those people don't buff up prior to going afk.

Let's stop all of this doom-and-gloom talk about: will I get banned for being afk @ the LIBRARY???? <-- seriously? This is really just trolling for trolling's sake. :/

The message here, kids? Don't do drugs.. err.. put yourself in a position where your toon will autokill mobs while you are AFK.

I know that there are times when my wife gets exasperated w/ me because there's something we need to do & I tell her: Okies. :) I just need to get to a safe spot. She waits, I get to safe spot & then afk in my house or whatnot.

Murkalael

Intermediate

Posts: 487

Location: Santo Andre - SP - Brazil

Occupation: Computer Fix Technician

  • Send private message

12

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 8:00pm

That's an interesting case to compare. So you cannot use ingame tools given by the game developer and we have to deal with the same bots on infernal gardens for months 24/7, in all 3 channels? So where's gameforge's common sense here? No wonder lots of people are leaving the game.

13

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 8:04pm

The Karlsruhe team is doing pretty good actually, I didn't see a dog farming bot when I had my alt in the Gardens. Heck, I was surprised that my alt was being attacked by dogs at all.

Back to topic:

Basically, someone must have seen the OP and reported him/her for suspected botting.

Did anyone report the others?

From what I gathered, the Karlsruhe team had to go through a LOT of backlog and pretty much learn RoM administration from the ground up. Froggie left them with very little documentation on how to do anything.
This post has already been reported.

14

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 8:30pm

afk with ingame skill that does auto-response = ban


see i first read the title and thought, auto-response as those afk addon where it tells other people you are afk when they say your name or whisper you,

your case is totally different, as someone stated in an earlier post, there was a similar case not too long ago about a r/m doing the same thing as the OP with dog meat area,
and was also ban, the old staff stated that afking while gaining xp/tp is ban able offense , so choose wisely to not afk in those sort of places,

but i am also curious about the new rules for banning players, do they get a first time warning 7 days, 2nd time caught 30 day ban, 3rd time and your out permanent ,

well on the bright side of things, i guess their website for reporting is working :stick:

ruisen2000

not a wallet warrior

Posts: 4,052

Location: here

Mood: Blink

  • Send private message

15

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 8:30pm

The problem is, with Enchanted throw and Vengance Sting, how can you tell if the person made a bad judgement in parking his toon, or if he's botting? In some cases, it might be obvious, like a toon parked right between 2 dog spawn locations, but its not always that obvious.

If someone is purposely taking advantage of it, then it is reasonable. But if someone is afk, its unreasonable to declare that they cannot be attacked by mobs while afk, since, obviously, its not within the powers of the players to tell mobs not to attack him.

If I'm going afk while questing, sometimes I'll keep my toon there, so I don't have to take the time to run back to where I was. Do I try to park my toon somewhere safe? Yes. Does that guarantee that I don't make mistakes and mobs spawn and attack me? no.
Noblewarrior
lv 98/98/89/60 M/W/P/K
Kikosi 98/50/60 Wl/Ch/M
the fail clothie tank~

Inactive

16

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 8:33pm

The problem is being able to tell who is botting, and who isn't, which may be impossible sometimes.

If someone is purposely taking advantage of it, then it is reasonable. But if someone is afk, its unreasonable to declare that they cannot be attacked by mobs while afk, since, obviously, its not within the powers of the players to tell mobs not to attack him.

If I'm going afk while questing, sometimes I'll keep my toon there, so I don't have to take the time to run back to where I was. Do I try to park my toon somewhere safe? Yes. Does that guarantee that I don't make mistakes and mobs spawn and attack me? no.
The problem is, when you park your toon anywhere, you may or may not be getting hit, but if you are, you aren't killing mobs and gaining xp/tp while you're afk. Evidently from what the OP said, he's been afk a few different times, each with hit reflect skill on and gained xp/tp.

17

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 8:46pm

The problem is, with Enchanted throw and Vengance Sting, how can you tell if the person made a bad judgement in parking his toon, or if he's botting? In some cases, it might be obvious, like a toon parked right between 2 dog spawn locations, but its not always that obvious.


That is why I asked the OP if the location where the toon was AFKing is reasonably assumed to be safe. Perhaps he can clarify this, but so far he quoted a part of my post that contained the question, but has not answered it. I don't want to infer that he is taking the 5th Amendment on this one, given that he is otherwise reasonable and not evasive, but it is still something he should've covered.
-- Rustyx --- 92R / 92S / 92M on Reni (Guild KnightShift). Yes, running the new FOTM R/M, cause I am not elf enough to be WD/S.

Oh, and people who have more than 3 classes are clinically insane.


karmakarma

Master Procrastinator

Posts: 442

Location: Miami

Occupation: Diesel Mechanic (semi-trucks/tractor-trailers)

  • Send private message

18

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 8:51pm

My quote options arent working but i want to point out something important from the OP...

"To summarize, please be aware that even if you use in game skills, but you are afk and that skill lets you do something automated (like reflected damage), you can be permanently banned. I wish someone posted the above so I could avoid my situation, as I would have never set it up if I knew it was considered botting by GF."

that is near the end of the first post, he clearly states that he did it intentionally, now as for the ban time, perm is extreme but it comes down to... Have you been banned or warned for it before?
LifeFire - Eternal - Grimdal
Mage/Priest/Knight
82/82/82

Give a macro, Take a Macro
Lifefire's Collections

Heddin

Trainee

  • "Heddin" started this thread

Posts: 126

Location: govinda

  • Send private message

19

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 9:05pm

Hi all,
Sorry I am at work and did not have time to reply.

Few things to clarify and answer some questions above:
1) Yes, by auto-response I meant auto-retaliate, was not sure what was best word to use, sorry for the confusion.
2) I did not know about other similar case, was not active on forums till last couple of months.
3) I did afk few times in between actively killing mobs with mobs in vicinity. As I said before and I might be naive nor have much experience with games( ROM is only MMO game I ever played), but I never considered using ingame auto-retaliate skill to be botting. Now, after talking with GMs, they consider it it as botting even though no external programs nor auto macro or whatever were used.
4) I was never banned before, not temp, nor recieved any warning that I know of.

Overall, unknownly I made this mistake, I admit it, I would never do it again. I posted it so other ppl wont make my mistake and hope someone somewhere with authority can read these posts and understand that people deserve second chance sometimes, and not everything they consider botting is the same.

I am sorry
Proud member of Bteam

karmakarma

Master Procrastinator

Posts: 442

Location: Miami

Occupation: Diesel Mechanic (semi-trucks/tractor-trailers)

  • Send private message

20

Monday, September 23rd 2013, 9:30pm

dont be sorry, bans happen to everyone, i have been banned for forgetting to agree to the email they send when you create a new account. just keep going back and forth with support until it gets resolved in a way you can accept and be happy with, dont give up, dont spam support, and dont be rude.. most likely they might help if its your first time ever being banned on your IP address, bans are not issued per account, they are issued to every account on your IP address so if you have another account that has been banned before they might not be so forgiving
LifeFire - Eternal - Grimdal
Mage/Priest/Knight
82/82/82

Give a macro, Take a Macro
Lifefire's Collections