You are not logged in.

Applications: [GameMaster: OPEN] | [Volunteer Testers: OPEN]


This forum will be permanently shut down on Friday 13.07.2018
Please copy or save all important information from old forum before they will be deactivated
We have moved to new board. https://forum.runesofmagic.gameforge.com/Come join us.

sickdust

Intermediate

  • "sickdust" started this thread

Posts: 323

Location: Mordor, Middle Earth

  • Send private message

1

Saturday, November 2nd 2013, 1:48pm

Server Transfer Idea

I was going to write this in response to a Doomsday post over on Grimdal entitled "Officially Dead" but i decided halfway through that i should make a separate thread on its own. Please... No witch hunting me on this, i'll accept constructive criticism but if you're here to just light a torch and try to run me out of my own thread, I would suggest spending your time on /r/mylittlepony you troll. :evil: This is just an IDEA and would love to hear feedback.

This is not a Doomsday Thread.

I have a random idea (and it could just be my "Up-all-night" Delirium speaking) that could be an Option if some choose to do so if a Server (any server really) were to be decisively shutdown to squeeze more players onto other servers for the Greater health of the Game. Now if you didn't already know, when Runes of Magic was made, it didn't have a Server Transfer Option built in mind. You can't just call/write up support and ask for them to move your lvl 80/80 toon over onto another server. You pretty much have to start fresh. And sometimes it's
not an easy decision to leave everything behind in the end, when you spent about 3 years + on a single server and all the items you've obtained. But there's some people that could say "You know what, i think it'd be pretty cool starting over". But to compensate players dedication to their toon and spark interest on them continuing to play this great game, here's my idea.

  • First off, One stipulation, i can only see this working as a "Once per account" thing, so there's no abusing the system.
I suggest having Tiers of Packages you could get depending on your toons level
  • Package A1, for people who have a Single Class toon that's 60+
    200 Diamonds, 500 Shells, 500 Ptokens, Small Puri Package, 30 Day Mount, Couple Random Gasha's

  • Package B1, for people who have a Single Class toon that's 70+
    250 Diamonds, 800 Shells, 800 Ptokens, Black Warhorse Mount (Permanent), Medium Puri Package, couple random gashas

  • Package C1, for people who have a Single Class toon that's 77+
    300 Diamonds, 1,000 Shells (max), 1,000 Ptokens, Black Warhorse Mount (Permanent), Large Puri Package, Little Goat of War, couple random gashas,
Bonus Package added for having a 2nd class Lvl

  • Package A2, for people who have a toon that has a secondary over 60+
    1x 1,000,000 TP Orb, Heavenly Black Wings, 10x Daily Reset Tickets, 100 Golden Eggs,

  • Package B2, for people who have a toon that has a secondary over 70+
    2x 1,000,000 TP Orb, House Contract, Mighty Phoenix Wings, 15x Daily Reset Tickets, 150 Golden Eggs,

  • Package C2, for people who have a toon that has a secondary over 77+
    3x 1,000,000 TP Orb, House Contract, Wings of Divine Incarnation, 20x Daily Reset Tickets, 200 Golden Eggs,

If you manage to have a 3rd class over 60+/70+/77+
  • Package A3
    Rune Disc (30 Days), Large Puri Pack, 10x Daily Reset Tickets

  • Package B3
    Rune Disc (30 Days), 3x Large Puri Packs, 15x Daily Reset Tickets

  • Package C3
    Rune Disc (Permanent), 5x Large Puri Packs, 20x Daily Reset Tickets
(More can be added if needed, this is just the beginning suggestion. I'm welcome to edit it upon discussing recommended Ideas you may have so we keep everyones ideas on the front page.)

Remember this is made to be incentive for experienced players to starting new toons on a different server upon any possible Server Shutdown Announcement and to reward the players for their achievements (making early lvl life a little easier) to make them want to keep playing.

For the process itself, i would suggest having a cookie-cutter fill out sheet asking for

Toon Name:
Current Server:
Class Lvl's + Screenshot (Important to have a screenshot for proof)
Newly Created Toon Name:
Server-To:

kinda thing

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Edit 1:
[!Important Update!]
Kalvan [Post #12] explains why Server Transfers is impractical. Good Read


Subscribe and join the Reddit /r/Runesofmagic Community!

This post has been edited 3 times, last edit by "sickdust" (Nov 4th 2013, 8:28am)


aardvark3

Professional

Posts: 866

Location: reni server

Occupation: retired

  • Send private message

2

Saturday, November 2nd 2013, 2:50pm

Sounds like a good idea except for one thing. By those levels almost everyone already has an excellent mount excellent wings and the little goat of war or something that does the same. Replace those with a level special costume that is available no where else and you would have a winner.

3

Saturday, November 2nd 2013, 4:35pm

What you're really competing with if you ask people to start from scratch is the opportunity to try a new game entirely. I suppose GameForge could offer a similar starter pack for one of their other games just as easily, though.

4

Saturday, November 2nd 2013, 4:59pm

if it is about players who stayed for long time and all the improvements they did for their toons... I prefer to see a complete toon transfer with everything except diamonds & gold. This should be allowed once for each toon with a charge of 500-1k diamonds to avoid unnecessary toon transfers.

Posts: 3,419

Location: Canada

Occupation: Company owner

Mood: Love

  • Send private message

5

Saturday, November 2nd 2013, 6:33pm

Well paying 1K diamonds or even 2K diamonds would be fine if i was on a server who didn't have enough population, at least being able to play with my original toon and all my stuff. I think this would be an excellent idea and could work, it would pay for the time to transfer the account etc, great idea.

K/P/S/M/W 98/98/98/98/98
Disturbed guild leader on mithras :thumbsup:
BTW i do live under a bridge, i am Green, i can dish it out as good as i get
There are no better server than Reni, best place to be!!!!!

sickdust

Intermediate

  • "sickdust" started this thread

Posts: 323

Location: Mordor, Middle Earth

  • Send private message

6

Sunday, November 3rd 2013, 12:43am

Sounds like a good idea except for one thing. By those levels almost everyone already has an excellent mount excellent wings and the little goat of war or something that does the same. Replace those with a level special costume that is available no where else and you would have a winner.

To clarify, I think your thinking that you would get these packages at those level's upon acquiring them much like you get from lvl 1-30 packages and the 35,40,45,50 ones you get from Ystra. I was suggesting getting these packages to the transferee upon getting their ticket reviewed/approved. So basically according to your toon on Server [.A], you get packages according to the Levels Achieved on Server [.B]

if it is about players who stayed for long time and all the improvements they did for their toons... I prefer to see a complete toon transfer with everything except diamonds & gold. This should be allowed once for each toon with a charge of 500-1k diamonds to avoid unnecessary toon transfers.

Frogster has clarified many times in the past that a complete toon transfer with items and levels included was impossible do to the servers structure. I'm sure GameForge would tell you the same. If a Transfer system could be done, it should have already been implemented and/or if it hasn't been attempted, i hope it can be accomplished. If not, Package systems much like i listed to transferee's would be of great value to those who don't want to just start with a blank canvas.
Subscribe and join the Reddit /r/Runesofmagic Community!

7

Sunday, November 3rd 2013, 5:46pm

They could definitely do items. Maybe not levels, but they could definitely recreate every item you owned. Every piece of gear, every costume, everything. They do that when you lose an item, they could do it when you switch servers.

Honestly I don't think that they CAN'T do server transfers, I just think they're not willing to put in the effort to figure out how.

Now on topic: I don't think that those packages are enough. That's really not much to start over with, especially if you were all endgame on the server you're switching from.
Borella - 100 W/M/S/R/P/K
VVV
If you play P/K in instances you're garbage


Cike

Rogue

Posts: 4,171

Occupation: Being Human

  • Send private message

8

Sunday, November 3rd 2013, 5:55pm

Honestly I don't think that they CAN'T do server transfers, I just think they're not willing to put in the effort to figure out how.

especially since they can do transfers to a beta server...and frogster did a server transfer for a friend of mine...even if server merge means taking 2 servers and moving every1 to a blank, new server, it can be done...
my r/p can outdps r/m. your name is stupid.

mages should stack dex. word.

9

Sunday, November 3rd 2013, 6:31pm

lol why would gameforge pay us or give some kind of incentive for us to move to unpopulated servers???

what?? is rom that dead?? LOL

but anyways, i would pay lots and lots of $$$$$ to get a transfer to another server on the US servers, or will even pay more mucho mucho grande deniro to get my account moved to the EU servers, or hell pay gameforge to create a whole new toon on EU servers, just want my levels, exp & tp, dont care about gold/gear!!!

10

Sunday, November 3rd 2013, 6:46pm

Only problem I see with server transfers is that all the endgamers will just congregate to one server to get more runs and the rest of the game will be left dead with nothing.
Borella - 100 W/M/S/R/P/K
VVV
If you play P/K in instances you're garbage


11

Sunday, November 3rd 2013, 9:06pm

yeah and anyone wanting said gear will be on that server, making everyone trying to cram on that one server. Really they should just look at taking low pop servers and merging them. Another game I play has been doing that for the last year... and I have had to switch 3 times... yes a pain in the rear, but boy does it help the community.


I am sure you are right Borella that they CAN do it, they either don't wanna put the time into doing it, or even more are worried about the unexpected problems that may come from it, so they would rather not do it. Which honestly I don't blame them. With RW coding, and everything else they do... I would hate to see them in the position to have to transfer anyone in a timely manner. Look at the Hackman's vacation and how long it was.. I would hate that to be the normal for a transfer lol.

Kalvan

Super Gamemaster

Posts: 2,053

Location: Lurking Amongst the Forums

  • Send private message

12

Monday, November 4th 2013, 7:49am

They could definitely do items. Maybe not levels, but they could definitely recreate every item you owned. Every piece of gear, every costume, everything. They do that when you lose an item, they could do it when you switch servers.

Honestly I don't think that they CAN'T do server transfers, I just think they're not willing to put in the effort to figure out how.


You think you know what you know, but what you don't know...

Every tiered and/or statted gear piece that Support has to re-create takes several hours of work for a single Support person. They have to spawn the item itself, and then spawn other items to get the stats (if it's a statted item), then apply them to the gear piece. And no, they can not spawn a specific durability value or spawn specific stats. And then they can rune drill the item as needed and replace the runes in it, as well as plus it to the correct level. As I said, this takes a fair amount of time to accomplish.

It takes longer if the gear piece is statted and tiered.

It's easier for a dirty tiered weapon, though they still have to spawn the weapon repeatedly until they get one where the durability matches the "lost" item.

Now, imagine how long it would take to replicate a fully-geared toon, all of the gear on it, for three classes. Then imagine how long it would take to replicate every item stored in every storage furniture piece, on every housekeeper, and then toss in every Item Shop item that the toon has in its possession (bank page(s), IS bank page, IS backpack included). All of this is for a single toon, mind you. Imagine the extra work it would take to do exactly the same things for the other toons sharing that account. And this does not include changing the toon's ID number and/or its name, which would be far easier to accomplish. Levels and total TP per class would be fairly simple, too.

But every item would have to be spawned or manipulated manually, one by one.

If you're wondering where I got this information, it is what I was told by Nytefall and other Support people.

What has been publicly stated by Community Management is accurate: Server transfers are either not possible at this time, or it is far too impractical to perform them due to the sheer amount of work it would take per character per account, and per server. There is no "magic bullet" or script in existence, at least not that I am aware of, that can accomplish what is being asked for.


Honestly I don't think that they CAN'T do server transfers, I just think they're not willing to put in the effort to figure out how.


See what I said to Borella above.

especially since they can do transfers to a beta server...and frogster did a server transfer for a friend of mine...even if server merge means taking 2 servers and moving every1 to a blank, new server, it can be done...

Apples and oranges, Cike. When toons were copied to the test server, that's precisely what was done. The character data was copied and then placed on the test server. The character ID number didn't matter--the next available ID number was used. The character name didn't matter because no character of that name existed on the test server. I don't know if the copied toons had or were given any gold or diamonds on the test server--I didn't take part in the project. I do know that however long the test project lasted, the players who took part in it did not get to "keep" their duplicated toons, nor was the data for those toons re-copied back to their original servers.
[ New Sig Coming. Watch This Space! ]


sickdust

Intermediate

  • "sickdust" started this thread

Posts: 323

Location: Mordor, Middle Earth

  • Send private message

13

Monday, November 4th 2013, 8:30am

Thanks for the epic explanation Kalvan :D Edited Original Post with a Direct Link to this in my Original Post :)
Subscribe and join the Reddit /r/Runesofmagic Community!

Cike

Rogue

Posts: 4,171

Occupation: Being Human

  • Send private message

14

Monday, November 4th 2013, 12:40pm

ty for the info kalvan....
my r/p can outdps r/m. your name is stupid.

mages should stack dex. word.

15

Monday, November 4th 2013, 3:17pm

sounds like the dupers/hackers had an easier time creating and modding gear than the support gms.

no wonder you cant get anything done.
Saito fix my wings

~ Aqualink removed part of signature deemed inappropriate

gigilomann

XxXGigilomannXxX

Posts: 2,213

Location: The one and only, Ohio.

Occupation: I Do Work

Mood: Love

  • Send private message

16

Monday, November 4th 2013, 3:28pm

They could definitely do items. Maybe not levels, but they could definitely recreate every item you owned. Every piece of gear, every costume, everything. They do that when you lose an item, they could do it when you switch servers.

Honestly I don't think that they CAN'T do server transfers, I just think they're not willing to put in the effort to figure out how.

Now on topic: I don't think that those packages are enough. That's really not much to start over with, especially if you were all endgame on the server you're switching from.
They COULD recreate the items, but they wont. They wont even recreate the items if it dissapears, so to say they COULD, thats a BIG IF.

sounds like the dupers/hackers had an easier time creating and modding gear than the support gms.

no wonder you cant get anything done.
lol, true, but the hackers/dupers were using outside programs, my question is, why cant GM's use the same to make it if it's way easier and faster? or is it not the same?
For you to live or die is in my hands, In Gigi we trust.

-"Retired as one of the best, Will always be remembered for KT, RT->RT Dia, and GCH"- -Palenque- -XxXGigilomannXxX- -P/K/S-


Amberwave

Intermediate

Posts: 369

Location: Chicagoland

  • Send private message

17

Monday, November 4th 2013, 4:36pm

What Kalvin has told us is that it is possible. So put a price on it. $100 to move one toon, $500 to move an account. It is a business, make some money. You find a need and you fill the need.

+1 about hackers making items. Any dura, any tier, any rune, 8 sockets...

18

Monday, November 4th 2013, 4:46pm

What Kalvin has told us is that it is possible. So put a price on it. $100 to move one toon, $500 to move an account.


There is far more to moving a toon than moving items, which is why OP is suggesting rewards instead of moves.

Quoted

It is a business, make some money. You find a need and you fill the need.


There has to be ROI on developing any tools that would do this properly. Not all needs get to be fulfilled.
-- Rustyx --- 92R / 92S / 92M on Reni (Guild KnightShift). Yes, running the new FOTM R/M, cause I am not elf enough to be WD/S.

Oh, and people who have more than 3 classes are clinically insane.


19

Monday, November 4th 2013, 11:10pm


sounds like the dupers/hackers had an easier time creating and modding gear than the support gms.

no wonder you cant get anything done.
+1000. It took people who hacked the game a matter of minutes to create a piece of gear. You're telling me the support staff takes HOURS to make one piece?




And this does not include changing the toon's ID number and/or its name, which would be far easier to accomplish. Levels and total TP per class would be fairly simple, too.

Apples and oranges, Cike. When toons were copied to the test server, that's precisely what was done. The character data was copied and then placed on the test server. The character ID number didn't matter--the next available ID number was used. The character name didn't matter because no character of that name existed on the test server. I don't know if the copied toons had or were given any gold or diamonds on the test server--I didn't take part in the project. I do know that however long the test project lasted, the players who took part in it did not get to "keep" their duplicated toons, nor was the data for those toons re-copied back to their original servers.
Okay. So they can copy toons and all their gear to a test server. Changing the toons ID number/character name is simple to accomplish, going off what you said. Levels and total TP would also be easy to accomplish. Simple. Copy the character data and place it on the destination server: the next available ID will be used. If name already exists, change the name of the character.

Your two explanations contradict themselves. If they have the capability to copy all the character data from one server to another, then they wouldn't need to manually spawn every item.

Regardless, my original point is true. They COULD do it, they just won't. Even if they had to spawn the items individually, which I sincerely doubt, they could do it. We've heard over and over that it's "not technically possible", but it is.
Borella - 100 W/M/S/R/P/K
VVV
If you play P/K in instances you're garbage


Amberwave

Intermediate

Posts: 369

Location: Chicagoland

  • Send private message

20

Monday, November 4th 2013, 11:11pm

Rusty, I totally agree. I just put out some prices. What ever it is, find the number. I knew a guy that painted murals in peoples homes, and he normally charged $300 - $600. He submitted a bid of $1800 on one job that he really did not want to do and the client said OK. Now it is worth his time. With transferring a toon, it is just a matter of man hours, it can be done. Put a price on it.